Film-Forward Review: [JACK SMITH AND THE DESTRUCTION OF ATLANTIS]

Reviews of Recent Independent, Foreign, & Documentary Films in Theaters and DVD/Home Video

Portrait of Jack Smith
Photo: Mike Sullivan

Rotten Tomatoes
Showtimes & Tickets
Enter Zip Code:

JACK SMITH AND THE DESTRUCTION OF ATLANTIS
Written & Directed by: Mary Jordan.
Produced by: Jordan & Kenneth Wayne Peralta.
Director of Photography: Mary Jordan & Jon Fordham.
Edited by: Alex Márquez.
Country of Origin: USA. 95 min. Not Rated.
With: Tony Conrad, Gary Indiana, Ken Jacobs, Judith Malina, Taylor Mead, Jonas Mekas, Mario Montez, Andrew Sarris, John Waters & Nick Zedd.
DVD Features:
Bonus clips: Glitter; Agosto Machado with Mario Montez on Jack the master; Lawrence Rinder on Jack’s photography; Ken Jacobs on Jack’s life as theater; Jack’s loft; Mario Montez on being Mario Montez; Nayland Blake on Jack and the art world; Holly Woodlawn on Jack’s influence; George Kuchar on Jack and his creatures; Colette and Vivienne Dick on Jack in Germany; Ronald Tavel on modeling for Jack; Judith Malina on art and capitalism; Sylvere Lotringer on Jack vs. capitalism

“I may look a little pale, but that’s because they don’t let me out of the safe very often.” These words appropriately open this bio-documentary. Outside the small circle of downtown New York intellectuals and avant-garde, Smith remained in obscurity, almost in spite of his most well-known film, Flaming Creatures, being banned in 22 states and four countries when it became part of the underground film movement in the 1960s. He was not what one would call successful in the conventional sense. He died of AIDS in 1989 without any money, leaving an incomplete film legacy. But to say anything was conventional about Smith would be moot: the guy was one of a kind, an artist who believed in a form and power of art that was very selective to audiences (or, as might be the case with his late-night screenings in the ‘70s, no audience at all). One interviewee comments he was a “self-made creature of fantasy,” and another, poet and collaborator Taylor Mead, describes Smith as an “extraterrestrial.”

I would be more inclined to go with the latter. Overall, Smith reminds me of the Hunter S. Thompson line in Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas about the lawyer Dr. Gonzo: “One of God’s prototypes. A high-powered mutant not even considered for mass production: too weird to live, and too rare to die.” Smith, after growing up in the rural dregs of depression-era squalor, was fascinated and compelled by expression through certain "abstractions" of outcasts. A kind of half outsider artist and half pre-Andy Warhol absurdist, Smith first went through a photography period, where he made color photos with extravagant costumes and sets and actors posing as if in little cinematic vignettes, simply because he couldn’t yet direct his films. For his real directorial work, he round up actors on Manhattan’s Lower East Side (one of which, a transvestite, Mario Montez, was named after one of Smith’s idols, B movie star Maria Montez), and blended in the fantastical with reality. Warhol ends up getting a chunk of screen time, and not without good reason. He was once quoted as saying Smith was the only person he would copy from, and one sees a very strange push and pull short-lived collaboration between them, but the two minds were too much into their own styles to really meet at one point.

What might be the most fascinating section of the documentary is where Smith’s rocky filmmaking career takes shape. Flaming Creatures, from the clips presented, is a manically profound farce, a rough 16mm glimpse into Smith’s consciousness, with no sense of pace or overall mood and unapologetically sexually ambiguous. (To say it’s outrageous and improvisational is putting it lightly.) But it’s alive and buzzing with a sense of humor and shameless, lascivious poetry. It was, upon its original underground release, banned, and labeled obscene by New York City.

But Smith was through and through a self-created visual anarchist, an originator of many of the avant-garde forms of filmmaking and art in the 1960s and beyond. Director Mary Jordan makes her film accessible and engrossing for an audience that might have not gone near a Jack Smith work in his heyday by unpretentiously revealing Smith in a way that compliments his style. As one sees through the interviews with friends, critics, admirers, actors, possible lovers, as well as the phantasmagoria in the bits and pieces of his work and audio clips, Smith made small waves when compared to the more noted filmmakers of his time like Fellini and Godard, but in such circles the effect was extraordinary. Jack Gattanella
April 10, 2007

DVD Extras: On a disc that has taken a year and a half since its (very) limited theatrical run to be released, there are about a dozen deleted segments.  However, they’re only bits—each is about a minute-and-a-half to two-minutes long. Interviews include Mario Montez (who interestingly confesses to having not dressed in drag since 1978) and filmmaker Ken Jacobs. “Colette and Vivienne Dick on Jack in Germany” covers a wacko trip to an international art fair. They’re curious enough (most notable is one regarding Smith’s loft and the battle between him and his landlord), but there’s a lack of an audio commentary or any really meaty interviews.  Jack Gattanella
September 16, 2008

Home

About Film-Forward.com

Archive of Previous Reviews

Contact us