FILM-FORWARD.COMReviews of Recent Independent, Foreign, & Documentary Films in Theaters and DVD/Home Video
TO BE AND TO HAVE
An illuminating documentary that's a breath of fresh air. With its
smooth camera work (there's very little hand-held shots) and largely
uninterrupted single-shot scenes, director Philibert captures more than
just a glimpse of a rural one-room school in central France. Georges
Lopez is the only teacher of 13 students, half in preschool, the other
half soon to be entering middle school. There's an instant nostalgic
pull at the sight of two small school children holding hands through the
snow. Yet, Philibert lucidly documents the problems within the
classroom: preschooler Jojo is too easily distracted; Olivier has
trouble multiplying (no matter how many slaps to the head from his
mother he receives); and the painfully shy Nathalie can hardly
communicate. To Be captures all too well the turmoil of growing
up. Although the camera is part of the classroom, and the children are
at times aware of its presence, they are so uninhibited that just
reading their expressions make subtitles unnecessary. What is even more
remarkable is the patience and consideration of Lopez, a possible
candidate for canonization. He has taught for 35 years, including 20 at
this school. The film is a reminder that teaching is an act of
improvisation, and Lopez is a master of it by facing whatever problem
comes along, whether he is reprimanding a bully or enforcing a promise
from Jojo to finish his artwork. Among the many heartbreaking moments:
Lopez comforting a boy whose father has cancer; and perhaps the most
moving, his interaction with Nathalie. As touching as Goodbye, Mr.
Chips (1939), this is an excellent companion to Spellbound,
another beguiling documentary about children. KT
|