Reviews of Recent Independent, Foreign, & Documentary Films in Theaters and DVD/Home Video
Directed by & Director of Photography: Pirjo Honkasalo. Produced by: Kristina Pervilä. Edited by: Niels Pagh Andersen & Pirjo Honkasalo. Music by: Sanna Salmenkallio. Released by: First Run/Icarus. Language: Russian, Chechen, Arabic & Finnish with English subtitles. Country of Origin: Finland. 106 min. Not Rated.
The 3 Rooms of Melancholia depicts three separate groups
of children who are living out, one way or another, the consequences of the
war between Russia and the separatist state Chechnya. It paints a moving portrait of the children,
the grown-ups around them, and what it
means day to day to be a part of an endless and violent conflict.
The first story - or room - covers the lives of young boys in a Russian
military academy. Many of them come from broken homes, wrecked by alcohol,
death or the war. The subtle sadness in their faces, their few laughs, and
the fact that boys of nine watch a video which contains footage of the
corpses of Chechen female suicide bombers say much more than any voiceover
could.
The same goes with the second episode. Three Grozny children have to leave
their ill mother and go live with a woman, Hadizhat Gataeva, who cares for
children in need. The opening scene of absolute urban desolation and the
very smallness of the room in which the mother lies - with her children
trying to feed her - is heartbreaking. These details, and the bus ride the
children and Gataeva go on while listening to the sounds of bombs
and artillery, give a sharpened sense of how the concept of normal has been
turned on its head.
Images also constitute an important part in understanding the third room,
set in a children's refugee camp in the neighboring republic of Ingushetia. In this segment, the people talk more about their
experiences, how much they hate the Russians and why - having been raped by
Russian soldiers, for example. It is sad, but also disturbing; many are the
children who will shape the country in the future and who, without fully
knowing what is happening, are already filled with hate.
All in all, the three rooms are clear-eyed accounts, relegating sound and
speech to the extremely necessary, though there are a few words, written and
spoken, that should have been translated. The pace is slow, almost religious in its continual
silence. The many close-ups of the
children's faces reveal scars that one supposes are due to the difficult
lives they live. The films biggest achievement, however, lies in capturing
the other, deeper unseen wounds that have not yet healed and might not ever mend.
Film-Forward.com, 180 Thompson Street, New York, NY 10012 - Contact us |