Reviews of Recent Independent, Foreign, & Documentary Films in Theaters and DVD/Home Video
THE GLEANERS AND I
In this poetic travelogue documentary, as well as entertaining contemplation of the vast
excess and waste of modern Western society, Agnès Varda, with her portable
digital camera, travels throughout urban and rural France gathering or gleaning
characters, art and social commentary from seemingly random destinations. The first stop
is the North of France and the potato fields, where Varda finds art in the mounds of
rejected potatoes, and where the modern world
encroaches on the old, or rather, where the modern world has failed to make
the old obsolete.
From the two-star chef to the psychotherapist wine maker, the oyster gatherers to the
fridge collector, we learn about the
history and penal codes that govern the ways of the gleaners as well as the
individual desires that drive people to glean. For Varda, the pleasure in gleaning is
discovering beauty in found objects.
In urban France we meet two of the most enduring characters: a
vegetarian with a master's degree who lives in a shelter where he teaches
immigrants French and a rubber-boot wearing man who finds
waste unacceptable. His passion is for sea birds, which he believes are dying
because of our over consuming society. His motto is birds first.
While Varda's passionate humanity and democratic eye paints a compassionate
picture of this diverse but committed group of gatherers, perhaps the least
integrated part of the film is Varda's self-reflexive story of aging and the
contemplation of her hands. But this is only a minor detraction in a gem of
a documentary.
DVD Extras: Varda continues her lively “wandering-road-documentary” in a
62-minute follow-up two years later. She sets out on the road to meet other
collectors and reunites with the calm and serious Alain F., still teaching
immigrants and living in subsidize housing. (Varda gracefully accepts his criticism that
the inclusion of her self-portrait in Gleaners was not necessary). What sets this
companion piece apart from the earlier film is the further glimpse into these
collectors’ lives, including two itinerant alcoholics who have started to set down roots. As
a result, this sequel is equally as compassionate as the first film.
|